fix(sdd): task-scoped review dispatch — single task reviewer, review-package script, eval-tuned#1717

Draft

obra wants to merge 43 commits into

devfrom

sdd-review-dispatch

Commits on Jun 9, 2026

Commits on Jun 10, 2026

Sync plan's Task 5 blocks with review fixes
obra
committed
Fix plan doc: correct Task 1 grep expectation; sync Task 5 story block
obra
committed
Sync plan: escaped pre() pattern in Task 5 checks block
obra
committed
Forbid controllers pre-judging reviewer findings
obra
committed
Require explicit model on subagent dispatch
obra
committed
Close three review blind spots found by defect tracing
obra
committed
Red Flags: never tell a reviewer what not to flag or pre-rate severity
obra
committed
Add phrase-level pre-judging triggers to reviewer prompt rule
obra
committed
Cut review-cost drivers: turn-aware models, inline diffs, scoped evidence
obra
committed
Merge per-task reviews into one task reviewer (iteration 2)
obra
committed
Spec: document cost iterations and the per-task review consolidation
obra
committed
Close the Minor-severity escape hatch
obra
committed
Make diff-pasting non-optional for task reviewer dispatch
obra
committed
Reviewer skepticism covers the implementer's design rationales
obra
committed
Hand reviewers the diff as a file, not a paste
obra
committed
Spec: record iterations 2-3 results and final frozen-config matrix
obra
committed
Describe the review design as current state, not as a delta
obra
committed
Add review-package script; close fix-dispatch test gap
obra
committed
Shared: unique review-package collateral names
obra
committed
Spec: positive-instruction redesign — audit results, micro-test method, writing-plans variants
obra
committed
Land eval-tuned combo: file handoffs, progress ledger, final-review package, REQUIRED model lines, reviewer risk budget
obra
committed
Adopt audited positive phrasings: evidence rule leads positive; fix-report completeness as checklist
obra
committed
Spec: record iterations 4-5 (variance honesty, structural fixes, final validated ranges)
obra
committed
Record writing-plans micro-test result: resolved, no change needed
obra
committed
Spec: strict-cost SDD experiment ladder — judgment as co-invariant, plan-side crispness first
obra
committed
Strict-cost spec: record batch A-E rung verdicts (L1 validated, L2 recon positive, L3 dead)
obra
committed

Commits on Jun 11, 2026