[feat] Add new template "type" for SEDAR reports - #511
Conversation
New version checklist
|
Checklist
|
Code Metrics Report
Code coverage of files in pull request scope (41.4%)
Reported by octocov |
c5ca77b to
c092a55
Compare
Schiano-NOAA
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
This is looking good, but it makes me wonder if this is needed. If there is no actual template, it might be worth more socializing that they are the same. The PR would then only make changes when office = "SEFSC" for authorship in the yml
|
@sbreitbart-NOAA please also make changes to the citation. Idk how involved that will be, but it still inputs author and I think this doesn't align with SEDAR? Not sure though |
0dd5360 to
95f9fe5
Compare
…skeleton except author = SEDAR only (no scientists' names added)
|
@lisaailloud-NOAA We are adding a report template that emulates a typical SEDAR report structure. Could you please take a look at the qmd files within the 'inst/templates/sedar' folder and let us know how we could improve the report structure, if at all? |
|
Thanks! The structure matches well with what we've been doing in the Gulf but I looked at the Atlantic side's reports (e.g. SEDAR92) and they are quite different. However, I don't think there's a way to make it work for every case.. Has your approach with other regions to include more or include less? I could set up a meeting to discuss this with representatives from all three branches? The only thing I would remove in the meantime is "constant catch" in the 06_projections qmd since we can put that under the OFL / ABC header. |
|
@lisaailloud-NOAA - thank you for your feedback! I can remove the "constant catch" part. @Schiano-NOAA Since you set up the other templates, do you have any thoughts re: Lisa's comment about how to make a template that works across a region, as this template is currently better suited for the Gulf vs. Atlantic? |
|
@sbreitbart-NOAA @lisaailloud-NOAA I think setting up a meeting with reps from all 3 regions would be best. Then we can at least come to an agreement on an outline for SEDAR if the standard guidelines cannot be adopted at this time. |
|
That sounds good. I'll look through their reports and compare with the guidelines. I'm thinking it might be easier for everyone to move to the standard guidelines rather than trying to make a SEDAR outline that works for all.. but I'll think on it and set up a meeting. |
|
@lisaailloud-NOAA Agreed! Maybe this push is needed then for the standard guidelines |
What is the feature?
How have you implemented the solution?
create_template()andcreate_yaml()Does the PR impact any other area of the project, maybe another repo?