Add governed agent identity evidence research batch

staging/batches/BATCH-2026-005/correction-retraction-review.json

@@ -0,0 +1,101 @@
+[
+  {
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-001",
+    "canonical_title": "Summary Analysis of Responses to the Request for Information Regarding Security Considerations for AI Agents",
+    "version_reviewed": "official HTML publication page accessed 2026-08-15",
+    "correction_status": "none_identified",
+    "retraction_status": "none_identified_on_canonical_page_as_of_2026-08-15",
+    "correction_or_retraction_locator": "canonical publisher or arXiv version page",
+    "substantive_effect": "none identified",
+    "checked_at": "2026-08-15",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-002",
+    "canonical_title": "Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework: Generative Artificial Intelligence Profile",
+    "version_reviewed": "July 2024; Editorial Review Board approval 2024-07-25; retrieved PDF SHA-256 recorded",
+    "correction_status": "no_correction_notice; PDF metadata modification noted",
+    "retraction_status": "none_identified_in_pdf_or_official_doi_resolution_as_of_2026-08-15",
+    "correction_or_retraction_locator": "PDF publication-history page and file metadata",
+    "substantive_effect": "none identified",
+    "checked_at": "2026-08-15",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003",
+    "canonical_title": "AI Agent Authentication and Authorization",
+    "version_reviewed": "revision 02; expires 2026-12-03",
+    "correction_status": "none_identified",
+    "retraction_status": "active_work_in_progress_not_retracted_as_of_2026-08-15",
+    "correction_or_retraction_locator": "canonical publisher or arXiv version page",
+    "substantive_effect": "none identified",
+    "checked_at": "2026-08-15",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004",
+    "canonical_title": "Identity Management for Agentic AI",
+    "version_reviewed": "October 2025",
+    "correction_status": "none_identified",
+    "retraction_status": "none_identified_on_official_pdf_or_publisher_url_as_of_2026-08-15",
+    "correction_or_retraction_locator": "canonical publisher or arXiv version page",
+    "substantive_effect": "none identified",
+    "checked_at": "2026-08-15",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-005",
+    "canonical_title": "Identity Management for Agentic AI: The new frontier of authorization, authentication, and security for an AI agent world",
+    "version_reviewed": "v1 submitted 2025-10-29",
+    "correction_status": "none_identified",
+    "retraction_status": "none_identified_on_arxiv_version_history_as_of_2026-08-15",
+    "correction_or_retraction_locator": "canonical publisher or arXiv version page",
+    "substantive_effect": "none identified",
+    "checked_at": "2026-08-15",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006",
+    "canonical_title": "AgentDojo: A Dynamic Environment to Evaluate Prompt Injection Attacks and Defenses for LLM Agents",
+    "version_reviewed": "v3; updated after a Llama implementation bug fix and travel-suite update",
+    "correction_status": "version_update_with_bug_fix",
+    "retraction_status": "no_retraction_identified;_v3_documents_bug_fix_update",
+    "correction_or_retraction_locator": "arXiv submission history comment for v3",
+    "substantive_effect": "v3 fixes a Llama implementation bug and updates the travel suite; earlier numerical results should not be used without version qualification",
+    "checked_at": "2026-08-15",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-007",
+    "canonical_title": "Agent Security Bench (ASB): Formalizing and Benchmarking Attacks and Defenses in LLM-based Agents",
+    "version_reviewed": "v4; paper and arXiv page state accepted at ICLR 2025",
+    "correction_status": "none_identified",
+    "retraction_status": "none_identified_on_arxiv_version_history_as_of_2026-08-15",
+    "correction_or_retraction_locator": "canonical publisher or arXiv version page",
+    "substantive_effect": "none identified",
+    "checked_at": "2026-08-15",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008",
+    "canonical_title": "Teams of LLM Agents can Exploit Zero-Day Vulnerabilities",
+    "version_reviewed": "v2 submitted 2025-03-30",
+    "correction_status": "none_identified",
+    "retraction_status": "none_identified_on_arxiv_version_history_as_of_2026-08-15",
+    "correction_or_retraction_locator": "canonical publisher or arXiv version page",
+    "substantive_effect": "none identified",
+    "checked_at": "2026-08-15",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009",
+    "canonical_title": "Practices for Governing Agentic AI Systems",
+    "version_reviewed": "2023; PDF metadata created 2023-12-18",
+    "correction_status": "none_identified",
+    "retraction_status": "none_identified_on_official_pdf_url_as_of_2026-08-15",
+    "correction_or_retraction_locator": "canonical publisher or arXiv version page",
+    "substantive_effect": "none identified",
+    "checked_at": "2026-08-15",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  }
+]

staging/batches/BATCH-2026-005/cross-project-mappings.json

@@ -0,0 +1,110 @@
+[
+  {
+    "mapping_id": "mapping-BATCH-2026-005-001",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-001",
+    "external_project_id": "executive-ai-research",
+    "external_snapshot_commit": "d205a6b2e6f4",
+    "match_status": "unmatched",
+    "external_record_id": null,
+    "ownership_status": "third_party",
+    "off_relationship": "none_identified",
+    "review_note": "Pinned snapshot manifest contains no production report records; no OFF-owned match can be asserted.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "mapping_id": "mapping-BATCH-2026-005-002",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-002",
+    "external_project_id": "executive-ai-research",
+    "external_snapshot_commit": "d205a6b2e6f4",
+    "match_status": "unmatched",
+    "external_record_id": null,
+    "ownership_status": "third_party",
+    "off_relationship": "none_identified",
+    "review_note": "Pinned snapshot manifest contains no production report records; no OFF-owned match can be asserted.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "mapping_id": "mapping-BATCH-2026-005-003",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003",
+    "external_project_id": "executive-ai-research",
+    "external_snapshot_commit": "d205a6b2e6f4",
+    "match_status": "unmatched",
+    "external_record_id": null,
+    "ownership_status": "third_party",
+    "off_relationship": "none_identified",
+    "review_note": "Pinned snapshot manifest contains no production report records; no OFF-owned match can be asserted.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "mapping_id": "mapping-BATCH-2026-005-004",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004",
+    "external_project_id": "executive-ai-research",
+    "external_snapshot_commit": "d205a6b2e6f4",
+    "match_status": "unmatched",
+    "external_record_id": null,
+    "ownership_status": "third_party",
+    "off_relationship": "none_identified",
+    "review_note": "Pinned snapshot manifest contains no production report records; no OFF-owned match can be asserted.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "mapping_id": "mapping-BATCH-2026-005-005",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-005",
+    "external_project_id": "executive-ai-research",
+    "external_snapshot_commit": "d205a6b2e6f4",
+    "match_status": "unmatched",
+    "external_record_id": null,
+    "ownership_status": "third_party",
+    "off_relationship": "none_identified",
+    "review_note": "Pinned snapshot manifest contains no production report records; no OFF-owned match can be asserted.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "mapping_id": "mapping-BATCH-2026-005-006",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006",
+    "external_project_id": "executive-ai-research",
+    "external_snapshot_commit": "d205a6b2e6f4",
+    "match_status": "unmatched",
+    "external_record_id": null,
+    "ownership_status": "third_party",
+    "off_relationship": "none_identified",
+    "review_note": "Pinned snapshot manifest contains no production report records; no OFF-owned match can be asserted.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "mapping_id": "mapping-BATCH-2026-005-007",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-007",
+    "external_project_id": "executive-ai-research",
+    "external_snapshot_commit": "d205a6b2e6f4",
+    "match_status": "unmatched",
+    "external_record_id": null,
+    "ownership_status": "third_party",
+    "off_relationship": "none_identified",
+    "review_note": "Pinned snapshot manifest contains no production report records; no OFF-owned match can be asserted.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "mapping_id": "mapping-BATCH-2026-005-008",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008",
+    "external_project_id": "executive-ai-research",
+    "external_snapshot_commit": "d205a6b2e6f4",
+    "match_status": "unmatched",
+    "external_record_id": null,
+    "ownership_status": "third_party",
+    "off_relationship": "none_identified",
+    "review_note": "Pinned snapshot manifest contains no production report records; no OFF-owned match can be asserted.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "mapping_id": "mapping-BATCH-2026-005-009",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009",
+    "external_project_id": "executive-ai-research",
+    "external_snapshot_commit": "d205a6b2e6f4",
+    "match_status": "unmatched",
+    "external_record_id": null,
+    "ownership_status": "third_party",
+    "off_relationship": "none_identified",
+    "review_note": "Pinned snapshot manifest contains no production report records; no OFF-owned match can be asserted.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  }
+]

staging/batches/BATCH-2026-005/doi-validation.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,10 @@
+source_id,doi,validation_method,resolution_status,resolved_target,note
+source-BATCH-2026-005-001,not reported,canonical source metadata reviewed; no DOI asserted,not_applicable,not applicable,A plausible NIST-style DOI was not assigned because it resolved to a missing PDF and was absent from canonical metadata.
+source-BATCH-2026-005-002,10.6028/NIST.AI.600-1,HTTPS GET via doi.org on 2026-08-15,resolved_http_200,https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/ai/NIST.AI.600-1.pdf,
+source-BATCH-2026-005-003,not reported,canonical source metadata reviewed; no DOI asserted,not_applicable,not applicable,
+source-BATCH-2026-005-004,not reported,canonical source metadata reviewed; no DOI asserted,not_applicable,not applicable,
+source-BATCH-2026-005-005,10.48550/arXiv.2510.25819,HTTPS GET via doi.org on 2026-08-15,resolved_http_200,https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.25819,
+source-BATCH-2026-005-006,10.48550/arXiv.2406.13352,HTTPS GET via doi.org on 2026-08-15,resolved_http_200,https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13352,
+source-BATCH-2026-005-007,10.48550/arXiv.2410.02644,HTTPS GET via doi.org on 2026-08-15,resolved_http_200,https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.02644,
+source-BATCH-2026-005-008,10.48550/arXiv.2406.01637,HTTPS GET via doi.org on 2026-08-15,resolved_http_200,https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01637,
+source-BATCH-2026-005-009,not reported,canonical source metadata reviewed; no DOI asserted,not_applicable,not applicable,

staging/batches/BATCH-2026-005/duplicate-report-review.json

@@ -0,0 +1,21 @@
+{
+  "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-005",
+  "checked_at": "2026-08-15",
+  "exact_hash_duplicate_groups": [],
+  "related_rendition_groups": [
+    {
+      "group_id": "related-BATCH-2026-005-001",
+      "normalized_work_identity": "Identity Management for Agentic AI",
+      "source_ids": [
+        "source-BATCH-2026-005-004",
+        "source-BATCH-2026-005-005"
+      ],
+      "relationship": "official OpenID rendition and arXiv v1 preprint of substantially the same intellectual work",
+      "hashes_identical": false,
+      "resolution": "Retain both source identities for bibliographic provenance but do not double-count their claims as independent evidence.",
+      "human_review_status": "pending"
+    }
+  ],
+  "discovery_duplicate_queue_checked": true,
+  "note": "No selected source collides with the five alternate-rendition groups in BATCH-2026-001; the OpenID/arXiv relationship is newly made explicit here."
+}

staging/batches/BATCH-2026-005/evidence-quality-assessments.json

@@ -0,0 +1,137 @@
+[
+  {
+    "assessment_id": "quality-BATCH-2026-005-001",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-001",
+    "dimensions": {
+      "attribution_strength": "high",
+      "methodological_transparency": "low_for_accessible_version",
+      "independence": "government_publisher",
+      "bibliographic_stability": "high",
+      "evidence_strength": "moderate_for_describing_commenter_themes_not_population_prevalence",
+      "unresolved": "Full report body and response-level method were not available from the canonical page."
+    },
+    "composite_score_used": false,
+    "reviewer_note": "Dimensions remain separate; no composite score or publication approval.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "assessment_id": "quality-BATCH-2026-005-002",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-002",
+    "dimensions": {
+      "attribution_strength": "high",
+      "methodological_transparency": "moderate_for_consensus_process",
+      "independence": "government_publisher",
+      "bibliographic_stability": "high_doi_resolved",
+      "evidence_strength": "strong_normative_reference_not_empirical_outcome_evidence",
+      "unresolved": "PDF metadata shows a 2025 modification date without a visible new edition statement."
+    },
+    "composite_score_used": false,
+    "reviewer_note": "Dimensions remain separate; no composite score or publication approval.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "assessment_id": "quality-BATCH-2026-005-003",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003",
+    "dimensions": {
+      "attribution_strength": "high",
+      "methodological_transparency": "not_applicable_non_empirical",
+      "independence": "multi_vendor_author_group",
+      "bibliographic_stability": "medium_due_to_expiring_draft",
+      "evidence_strength": "strong_for_current_proposal_weak_for_interoperability_outcomes",
+      "unresolved": "Future revisions may change normative language or identifier choices."
+    },
+    "composite_score_used": false,
+    "reviewer_note": "Dimensions remain separate; no composite score or publication approval.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "assessment_id": "quality-BATCH-2026-005-004",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004",
+    "dimensions": {
+      "attribution_strength": "high",
+      "methodological_transparency": "appropriate_for_white_paper_but_source_selection_not_reported",
+      "independence": "standards_community_publisher",
+      "bibliographic_stability": "high_official_pdf",
+      "evidence_strength": "moderate_normative_synthesis_not_empirical",
+      "unresolved": "Substantially the same intellectual work appears as arXiv:2510.25819v1."
+    },
+    "composite_score_used": false,
+    "reviewer_note": "Dimensions remain separate; no composite score or publication approval.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "assessment_id": "quality-BATCH-2026-005-005",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-005",
+    "dimensions": {
+      "attribution_strength": "high",
+      "methodological_transparency": "appropriate_for_preprint_synthesis",
+      "independence": "multi_author_preprint",
+      "bibliographic_stability": "high_arxiv_doi_resolved",
+      "evidence_strength": "moderate_normative_synthesis_not_empirical",
+      "unresolved": "Treat as a related rendition, not an independent evidentiary replication of the OpenID report."
+    },
+    "composite_score_used": false,
+    "reviewer_note": "Dimensions remain separate; no composite score or publication approval.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "assessment_id": "quality-BATCH-2026-005-006",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006",
+    "dimensions": {
+      "attribution_strength": "high",
+      "methodological_transparency": "high",
+      "independence": "academic_with_disclosed_industry_affiliations",
+      "bibliographic_stability": "high_arxiv_and_neurips_records",
+      "evidence_strength": "strong_for_benchmark_conditions_not_real_world_incidence",
+      "unresolved": "Confidence-interval construction and raw row numerators are not stated in the reviewed tables."
+    },
+    "composite_score_used": false,
+    "reviewer_note": "Dimensions remain separate; no composite score or publication approval.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "assessment_id": "quality-BATCH-2026-005-007",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-007",
+    "dimensions": {
+      "attribution_strength": "high",
+      "methodological_transparency": "high_for_benchmark_structure",
+      "independence": "academic",
+      "bibliographic_stability": "high_arxiv_doi_resolved",
+      "evidence_strength": "moderate_to_strong_for_benchmark_conditions",
+      "unresolved": "Venue acceptance is author/arXiv-reported; OpenReview verification was unavailable in this run. Headline average lacks uncertainty and a compact denominator statement."
+    },
+    "composite_score_used": false,
+    "reviewer_note": "Dimensions remain separate; no composite score or publication approval.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "assessment_id": "quality-BATCH-2026-005-008",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008",
+    "dimensions": {
+      "attribution_strength": "high",
+      "methodological_transparency": "moderate",
+      "independence": "academic_with_platform_coordination_disclosed",
+      "bibliographic_stability": "high_arxiv_doi_resolved",
+      "evidence_strength": "moderate_for_selected_sandbox_cases",
+      "unresolved": "Nonrelease of code/prompts limits replication; funding and conflict disclosures are absent."
+    },
+    "composite_score_used": false,
+    "reviewer_note": "Dimensions remain separate; no composite score or publication approval.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  },
+  {
+    "assessment_id": "quality-BATCH-2026-005-009",
+    "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009",
+    "dimensions": {
+      "attribution_strength": "high",
+      "methodological_transparency": "appropriate_for_policy_analysis",
+      "independence": "company_published",
+      "bibliographic_stability": "high_official_pdf",
+      "evidence_strength": "moderate_normative_policy_analysis_not_empirical",
+      "unresolved": "Publication day, funding, affiliations, conflicts, and external review status are not reported in the PDF."
+    },
+    "composite_score_used": false,
+    "reviewer_note": "Dimensions remain separate; no composite score or publication approval.",
+    "human_review_status": "pending"
+  }
+]