github-devloop implementation for #373

[ElonSG]

github-devloop implementation PR for issue #373

[ElonSG]

github-devloop PR child open

[ElonSG]

github-devloop PR is ready for review

[ElonSG]

github-devloop PR is ready for review

[ElonSG]

github-devloop PR review decision: reject
Verdicts: teleology=reject parsimony=reject fidelity=reject natural-ownership=reject proportional-containment=reject
Blocking gap: missing same-prose control

teleology:
Established controlled-variable regression testing requires the negative control to differ only in the structured field under test. No peer claim defeats this; every peer independently confirms it. The control uses "server overloaded" while the typed fixture uses "capacity unavailable" at crates/fkst-framework/tests/sdk_codex.rs:3125 and :3133, so acceptance item 4 does not prove that prose is ignored. Use identical messages and omit only codex_error_info.

parsimony:
No peer claim moved me; every peer confirms the locked root concern that acceptance item 4 is not isolated. The adapter correctly preserves the producer field from turn.failed.error.codex_error_info at crates/fkst-framework/src/sdk_codex.rs:394-417 and projects UNKNOWN only at Lua exposure at crates/fkst-framework/src/sdk_codex.rs:370-374, but the regression fixtures change both prose and typed-field presence: "server overloaded" at crates/fkst-framework/tests/sdk_codex.rs:3125 versus "capacity unavailable" at crates/fkst-framework/tests/sdk_codex.rs:3133. That leaves prose classification unexcluded, so the explicit acceptance proof remains unmet.

fidelity:
The root claim is lossless, non-classifying transport, but acceptance item 4 is the proof that establishes it and the fixture changes two variables: the control emits "server overloaded" at crates/fkst-framework/tests/sdk_codex.rs:3125, while the typed case emits "capacity unavailable" plus codex_error_info at crates/fkst-framework/tests/sdk_codex.rs:3133. A prose classifier could therefore satisfy the test; the peers' shared objection stands, so the messages must be identical with only the typed field omitted.

natural-ownership:
The peers do not defeat the locked objection: established differential-test practice requires holding prose and exit status constant while varying only the typed field. This test changes both variables: the control says "server overloaded" at crates/fkst-framework/tests/sdk_codex.rs:3125, while the typed fixture says "capacity unavailable" at crates/fkst-framework/tests/sdk_codex.rs:3133. Therefore acceptance item 4 remains unable to rule out prose classification.

proportional-containment:
Established controlled-experiment practice requires a negative control to vary only the discriminant under test. The peers’ shared same-prose claim corroborates my locked position: although production extracts only codex_error_info (sdk_codex.rs), acceptance item 4 explicitly requires the same human message, while the control emits "server overloaded" and the typed case emits "capacity unavailable" (sdk_codex.rs, sdk_codex.rs). Thus the required proof remains incomplete.

⟦AI:FKST⟧

[ElonSG]

github-devloop merge gate failed: missing same-prose control
Reproduce locally with scripts/run.sh test from the repository root.

[ElonSG]

github-devloop timeout redrive attempt: fixing 1

⟦AI:FKST⟧

[ElonSG]

github-devloop timeout redrive attempt: fixing 1

⟦AI:FKST⟧

[ElonSG]

github-devloop fix pushed for re-review

Previous reviewed head: be5f8e4
New head: 1548bf9

[ElonSG]

github-devloop PR is ready for review

[ElonSG]

github-devloop PR review decision: approve
Verdicts: teleology=approve parsimony=approve fidelity=approve natural-ownership=approve proportional-containment=approve

teleology:
The named gap is closed: the fix changes the typed fixture’s message to "server overloaded", matching the untyped control exactly while retaining the same exit code, so only codex_error_info differs at crates/fkst-framework/tests/sdk_codex.rs:3125 and :3133; this is the controlled-variable proof required by acceptance item 4, and the one-line test-only fix introduces no in-scope regression.

parsimony:
The named gap is closed: the control and typed fixtures now both emit "message":"server overloaded" and exit 1, while only the typed fixture includes codex_error_info (sdk_codex.rs, sdk_codex.rs). This removes the prior narrative-over-verification smell without introducing a magic number or symptom branch; the fix delta is test-only. ⟦AI:FKST⟧

fidelity:
Established schema-first adapter practice is satisfied, and the named gap is closed: the typed and control fixtures now use identical "server overloaded" prose and exit code 1, differing only in codex_error_info presence (crates/fkst-framework/tests/sdk_codex.rs:3125, crates/fkst-framework/tests/sdk_codex.rs:3133); production extracts only that producer field (crates/fkst-framework/src/sdk_codex.rs:412), while the integration test verifies Lua exposure, adoption artifacts, single-spawn replay, the UNKNOWN control, and successful stdout projection (crates/fkst-framework/tests/sdk_codex.rs:3155, crates/fkst-framework/tests/sdk_codex.rs:3172, crates/fkst-framework/tests/sdk_codex.rs:3181, crates/fkst-framework/tests/sdk_codex.rs:3193). The re-review delta changes only the fixture prose, introducing no within-scope regression. ⟦AI:FKST⟧

natural-ownership:
The named gap is closed: the control and typed fixtures now use identical "server overloaded" prose and exit code, differing only by the presence of codex_error_info at sdk_codex.rs and sdk_codex.rs. The repair introduces no runtime change and now proves that producer metadata, rather than prose or status, owns the classification.

proportional-containment:
The named gap is closed: the one-line repair makes the typed and untyped failures share identical prose and exit status while varying only codex_error_info, so the control now excludes prose and exit-code classification. The change is confined to the existing integration fixture and introduces no in-scope regression or speculative abstraction. This is a source-backed review; tests were not executed because the checkout is read-only, and CI remains a later merge gate. ⟦AI:FKST⟧

⟦AI:FKST⟧

[ElonSG]

github-devloop is merging PR #374

[ElonSG]

github-devloop merged PR #374