Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
23 lines (19 loc) · 2.63 KB

QUALITY.md

File metadata and controls

23 lines (19 loc) · 2.63 KB

Quality Status

Module Grade Reason Required Improvement
Product documentation A- SDK/reference DEX, 4-Layer, immutable Element/Recipe versioning, compiled RecipeBinding Manifest, RFQ와 production ERC-3643 onboarding runbook/CLI 흐름이 정합함 production RFQ/OrderBook 운영 evidence와 법률 승인 기준 보강
Harness / agent workflow B HE-001, DOC-001, RFQ-001 상태·검증 이력이 존재함 PR/CI 결과와 feature state 지속 동기화
Product Solidity B+ immutable Element/Recipe registration, canonical recipeKey aliasing, bounded compiled enforcement plans, lifecycle/history, Compliance Core, Router, hardened AMM/RFQ adapter가 컴파일·테스트됨 production custody/partial fill, LP onboarding과 OrderBook 미구현
Foundry tests B unit/integration, canonical Uniswap v3 callback, RFQ failure path와 live Anvil E2E 존재 추가 adversarial/security tests
Compliance data SDK A- Provider-neutral acquisition, audit, person-group state and TA/KYC evidence coordinator have smoke/conformance coverage with PII-free fail-closed behavior Replace reference in-memory KYC store with operator transactional HA/WORM storage and audited provider adapters
RFQ reference service / host A- EIP-712 SDK, module conformance, local demo HTTP API/CLI, durable coordinator/reference file store와 별도 production host hardening smoke가 존재함 HA transactional coordinator store, production signer custody, shared limiter/WORM audit/TLS 운영 통합 필요
tools/deploy-v3 B profile 단위 테스트와 pinned core artifact integration 존재 unified production deployment orchestration 추가
CI / static analysis B GitHub Actions와 local check가 동일한 repository-wide gate를 실행해 Foundry, 서비스 smoke, dashboard와 deploy-v3를 검증함 medium warning budget과 독립 보안 분석 도입
Security documentation A- trust boundary, direct venue boundary, strengthen-only compiled enforcement, exact reason propagation, RFQ hardening and production onboarding no-broadcast/no-inventory-mutation verifier semantics를 문서화함 production custody/incident runbook과 external audit checklist 보강

Grade Guide

  • A: 테스트, 문서, 에러 처리와 관찰 가능성이 충분함
  • B: 대체로 안정적이나 일부 검증이나 문서가 부족함
  • C: 작동 기반은 있으나 구조·검증에 리스크가 있음
  • D: 구현 또는 검증 기반이 부족함

등급은 인상이나 진척률이 아니라 현재 저장소에서 확인 가능한 검증 근거를 기준으로 갱신한다.